Make-or-Buy Decision: Managing Costs and Risks

Tori Katz
March 26, 2024

Guide to Make-or-Buy Decisions: Strategic, Tactical, and Component Layers

We can only discuss make-or-buy decisions after first delving into the three essential layers. 

Strategic Decision Criteria: Manufacturing Operations, Product Development, and Supplier Selection

The first layer of strategic decision criteria is the foundation of your make-or-buy decision. It's where you decide on the overall direction of your manufacturing operations, product development, and supplier selection. Remember, your decisions will define your firm's production process and influence your production costs. You should evaluate your production capacity and skills to manufacture in-house.

Tactical Decisions: Responding to Temporary Shifts in Production Capacity

In the second layer, you address temporary shifts in production capacity. Is there a sudden surge in demand or a hiccup in your supply chain? Your tactical decision on making or buying should consider these short-term fluctuations in the production process. The goal is to ensure your firm remains flexible and resilient, all while keeping an eye on production costs.

Component Decisions: Evaluating the Purchase Price and Production Costs of Specific Product Components

Lastly, we have the component decisions. This is where you evaluate individual product components' purchase price and production costs; whether a tiny bolt or a complex microchip, your choice to manufacture in-house or buy can significantly impact your overall costs.

Weighing Production Costs in Make-or-Buy Analysis

In the complex decision-making process of make-or-buy analysis, companies must evaluate production costs carefully. 

Economic Factors: Comparing Costs of In-House Manufacturing vs. Outsourcing

When deciding between in-house production and outsourcing, compare all costs. This includes direct costs like labor and materials and indirect costs like monitoring and transportation. By comparing these, executives can make the best financial decisions.

  • Compare direct costs like labor and materials.
  • Account for indirect costs such as monitoring and transportation.
  • Contrast total costs of in-house production and outsourcing.
  • Optimize financial resources with detailed cost analysis.

Quality Assurance: Managing Product Quality Risks

Product quality is critical in any make-or-buy decision. Executives must assess the risks to product quality when deciding. Detailed analysis helps identify and address potential issues, ensuring product quality is maintained.

  • Assess risks to product quality in make-or-buy decisions.
  • Identify potential quality issues through thorough assessments.
  • Develop strategies to mitigate identified risks.
  • Ensure product quality through meticulous attention to detail.

Intellectual Property: Protecting Patents and IP Rights

Protecting intellectual property is vital. In make-or-buy decisions, consider how each option affects IP rights. In-house production often offers better protection against unauthorized use or infringement. This is crucial for safeguarding valuable IP.

  • Evaluate impact on patents, copyrights, and other IP rights.
  • In-house production can better safeguard intellectual property.
  • Minimize risk of unauthorized use or infringement.
  • Emphasize the importance of IP protection in the decision process.

Supplier Relationships: Building Strong Partnerships

Building strong relationships with reliable suppliers is key. Good supplier relationships reduce risks and offer benefits like better pricing and delivery terms. This is important for effective risk management and cost control in production.

  • Build strong relationships with reliable suppliers.
  • Reduce risks and gain benefits like better pricing and delivery terms.
  • Improve risk management and cost control in production through solid supplier partnerships.

Did you know ?

Integrating Purchasing Software into Make-or-Buy Decisions

Streamlining Decisions: Automating Data Collection

Executives need efficient decision-making in fast-paced environments. Purchasing software automates data collection and analysis, making it easier to gather and analyze key data like production costs and risk exposure. This saves time and helps make better decisions.

  • Implement Purchasing Software: Select and install a robust purchasing software that fits the company's needs.
  • Integrate Systems: Ensure the purchasing software integrates seamlessly with existing ERP and accounting systems.
  • Automate Data Input: Set up automated data entry for production costs, purchase prices, and risk metrics.
  • Centralize Data Storage: Use a centralized database for all procurement-related data.
  • Utilize Real-Time Analytics: Enable real-time data analysis and reporting features.
  • Train Staff: Train employees to use the new software and interpret data outputs.
  • Monitor and Update: Regularly monitor the system's performance and update it as necessary to keep up with technological advancements.

Supplier Management: Tracking Performance and Reducing Costs

Good supplier relationships are crucial. Software tools help track and evaluate supplier performance, identify issues early, and reduce monitoring needs. This improves supplier relationships and cuts monitoring costs.

  • Use Supplier Management Software: Deploy software specifically designed for supplier management.
  • Track Key Metrics: Monitor supplier performance metrics such as delivery times, quality, and compliance.
  • Set Up Alerts: Configure alerts for any deviations from agreed-upon performance standards.
  • Conduct Regular Reviews: Schedule regular performance reviews with suppliers.
  • Foster Communication: Use the software to streamline supplier communication and feedback loops.
  • Identify and Address Issues: Quickly identify potential issues through the software and take proactive measures.
  • Negotiate Better Terms: Use performance data to negotiate improved terms with suppliers.

Cost Analysis: Finding Savings and Conducting Cost-Benefit Analyses

A thorough cost examination is essential. Purchasing software identifies cost-saving opportunities and inefficiencies. Advanced data analysis helps executives conduct detailed cost-benefit analyses, ensuring strategic decisions that maximize value and minimize expenses.

  • Implement Cost Analysis Software: Use software capable of advanced cost analysis and financial modeling.
  • Identify Cost Drivers: Identify and track primary cost drivers within the production and procurement processes.
  • Analyze Historical Data: Use historical data to find patterns and potential savings.
  • Run Simulations: Conduct simulations to predict the financial impact of different make-or-buy scenarios.
  • Perform Regular Audits: Regularly audit costs and compare them to industry benchmarks.
  • Identify Redundancies: Find and eliminate redundant processes and inefficiencies.
  • Implement Recommendations: Apply insights from cost-benefit analyses to refine procurement strategies.
  • Review and Adjust: Continuously review and adjust strategies based on new data and changing conditions.

Detailed Cost Analysis in Make-or-Buy Decisions

A detailed cost analysis is crucial for high-level executives in hardware-centered, procurement-heavy companies when making or buying decisions. This section goes beyond surface-level examination and explores key elements of cost analysis to enable informed decision-making.

Marginal Costing: Compare Supplier Price vs. Internal Costs

When deciding to make or buy, compare supplier prices with in-house production costs. For example, if a supplier offers a part for $50, but in-house production costs are $45 including labor, materials, and overhead, making in-house might save $5 per unit.

Opportunity Cost: Evaluate Benefits Lost

Assess the potential benefits lost by choosing one option over another. If outsourcing saves $10,000 in production costs but in-house production could generate an extra $12,000 in sales due to faster delivery times, the opportunity cost of outsourcing is $2,000.

Break-even Analysis: Find the Optimal Decision Point

Use break-even analysis to determine when production costs equal purchase prices. If producing in-house costs $30,000 initially with $10 per unit thereafter, and buying costs $15 per unit, the break-even point is at 6,000 units ($30,000/$5). Beyond this point, making in-house becomes cheaper.

Explore our comprehensive guide on purchasing policy best practices to enhance your procurement strategy.

Further Factors Influencing Make-or-Buy Decisions

Quantitative Factors: Assess Production Capacity, Costs, and Inventory

When deciding to make or buy, consider production capacity, costs, and inventory. For example, if in-house production can meet demand but costs $500,000 annually, while outsourcing costs $450,000, outsourcing may save $50,000. However, if production capacity limits are reached, leading to delays or increased inventory costs, in-house production might be more efficient. Analyze these aspects to determine which option best fits your company's needs.

Qualitative Factors: Evaluate Resource Management, Competitive Advantage, and Expertise

Resource management, competitive advantage, and expertise are crucial in make-or-buy decisions. Assess if your company has the resources to manage in-house production effectively. For instance, if outsourcing allows your team to focus on core competencies, it might provide a competitive edge. If in-house production leverages unique expertise, it could enhance product quality and innovation. Weigh these qualitative factors to align decisions with strategic goals and strengthen your company's market position.

Practical Example

Suppose your company has an annual production capacity of 10,000 units. In-house production costs $50 per unit, but outsourcing costs $45 per unit. However, outsourcing may involve longer lead times and potential quality issues. If maintaining quality and timely delivery is crucial, in-house production might be worth the extra cost. Conversely, if cost savings are a priority and quality control can be managed effectively with suppliers, outsourcing could be the better option.

By considering both quantitative and qualitative factors, executives can make informed make-or-buy decisions that balance costs, efficiency, and strategic goals.

The Value of Purchasing Software in Make-or-Buy Decisions

Purchasing software offers significant value to high-level executives in hardware-centered, procurement-heavy companies regarding make-or-buy decisions. This section highlights the advantages of utilizing e-procurement software and how it supports decision-making processes.

E-Procurement Software Advantages: Streamlining Procurement Processes, Managing Transportation Costs, and Improving Supplier Relationships

E-procurement software brings a host of advantages to the table. By streamlining procurement processes, it enhances efficiency and reduces administrative burdens. Additionally, it aids in managing transportation costs by optimizing logistics and supply chain operations. Furthermore, e-procurement software facilitates improved supplier relationships by providing collaboration, communication, and performance monitoring tools. These software-driven advantages contribute to enhanced decision-making and overall procurement effectiveness.

E-Procurement Software's Role in Decision Making: Data Analytics, Real-Time Supplier Performance Monitoring, and Collaborative Tools

In making-or-buy decisions, e-procurement software is pivotal in decision-making processes. It offers powerful data analytics capabilities, enabling executives to extract meaningful insights from vast procurement-related data. Real-time supplier performance monitoring allows executives to assess supplier reliability, quality, and responsiveness in real time, contributing to better decision-making. 

Moreover, collaborative tools within the software enable seamless communication and collaboration with internal stakeholders and external suppliers. By leveraging these features, executives can make well-informed decisions, optimize procurement strategies, and drive overall business success.

Key Takeaways: Guide to Make-or-Buy Decisions

Strategic Decision Criteria: Manufacturing Operations, Product Development, and Supplier Selection

  • Decide on the overall direction of manufacturing, product development, and supplier selection.
  • Evaluate in-house production capacity and skills.
  • Your decisions influence production processes and costs.

Tactical Decisions: Responding to Temporary Shifts in Production Capacity

  • Address temporary shifts like demand surges or supply chain issues.
  • Ensure flexibility and resilience in your production process.
  • Aim to maintain control over production costs.

Component Decisions: Evaluating the Purchase Price and Production Costs of Specific Product Components

  • Assess costs of individual components, such as bolts or microchips.
  • Decide to manufacture in-house or buy based on cost impact.
  • Detailed evaluation can significantly influence overall costs.

Weighing Production Costs in Make-or-Buy Analysis

  • Economic Factors: Compare direct costs like labor and materials, and indirect costs like monitoring and transportation. Compare a supplier's $50 per part cost vs. $45 in-house production cost.
  • Quality Assurance: Assess and manage product quality risks. Identify potential quality issues and develop strategies to mitigate them.
  • Intellectual Property: Protect patents and IP rights. In-house production often provides better IP protection.
  • Supplier Relationships: Build strong partnerships to reduce risks and gain benefits. Reliable suppliers can improve pricing and delivery terms.

Integrating Purchasing Software into Make-or-Buy Decisions

  • Streamlining Decisions: Automate data collection and analysis. Purchasing software can save time by automating data entry and analysis.
  • Supplier Management: Track performance and reduce monitoring costs. Software helps identify and address issues early, improving supplier relationships.
  • Cost Analysis: Find savings and conduct cost-benefit analyses.Software identifies inefficiencies, helping executives make strategic decisions.

Further Factors Influencing Make-or-Buy Decisions

  • Quantitative Factors: Assess production capacity, costs, and inventory. If in-house production costs $500,000 annually vs. $450,000 outsourcing, outsourcing saves $50,000.
  • Qualitative Factors: Evaluate resource management, competitive advantage, and expertise. Outsourcing might allow the team to focus on core competencies, providing a competitive edge.

By considering these strategic, tactical, and component layers, as well as detailed cost analysis and additional factors, executives can make informed make-or-buy decisions that balance costs, efficiency, and strategic goals.

FAQ: Understanding the Make-or-Buy Decision in Hardware-Centered Companies

What are the three tiers of make-or-buy decisions?

The three tiers of make-or-buy decisions involve strategic decision criteria, tactical decisions, and component decisions. These layers encompass manufacturing operations, production capacity shifts, and evaluating specific product components.

Why is it essential to weigh production costs in a make-or-buy analysis?

Evaluating production costs is crucial as it helps high-level executives make informed decisions that optimize financial resources and maximize profitability.

What economic factors should be considered in make-or-buy decisions?

Economic factors include comparing total production costs of in-house manufacturing versus outsourcing, considering direct and indirect costs.

How does product quality assessment affect the make-or-buy decision?

Assessing the risk exposure associated with product quality helps executives ensure that quality is not compromised and identify strategies to mitigate potential risks.

Why is intellectual property safeguarding important in the make-or-buy decision process?

Safeguarding intellectual property minimizes the risk of unauthorized use or infringement, making it vital to consider when conducting a make-or-buy analysis.

How do supplier interactions contribute to effective risk management and cost control?

Building strong relationships with reliable suppliers reduces risk exposure, enhances negotiation power, and improves cost control in the production process.

How can purchasing software enhance make-or-buy decisions?

Purchasing software streamlines decision-making processes by automating data collection and analysis, tracking supplier performance, identifying cost-saving opportunities, and conducting thorough cost-benefit analyses.

What is marginal costing in make-or-buy decisions?

Marginal costing involves comparing the purchase price quoted by suppliers with the production costs incurred if the item is manufactured in-house, helping executives determine the cost implications of each option.

How does break-even analysis assist in the make-or-buy decision process?

Break-even analysis identifies the point at which in-house production costs equal the purchase price, helping executives determine the optimal decision point and mitigate financial risks.

What other factors influence make-or-buy decisions?

When companies decide whether to make something themselves or buy it from someone else, they look at several important points:

  • Can We Make Enough? If they can't produce enough to meet demand, they might need to buy from others.
  • What's the Cost? They compare all costs, including materials, labor, and long-term expenses like upkeep and training, for both making and buying.
  • How Will This Affect Our Inventory? Making or buying affects how much stock they hold, which impacts how much money is tied up in products.
  • Where Should We Use Our Resources? They decide if their time, staff, and money are better used making the product or focused elsewhere.
  • Do We Have an Edge? If they're really good at making something, they might stick to making it. If not, they might buy instead.
  • Do We Know How to Make It Well? If they don't have the know-how to make it well, they might have to buy it.
  • How Fast Can We Get It to Customers? If outsourcing helps get the product out faster, they might choose to buy.
  • Do We Need to Be Flexible? If they need to change how much they make quickly, buying might give them more flexibility.
  • Can We Keep Up with Tech? If staying updated with technology for making the product is too hard or expensive, they might buy instead.
  • What About Laws and Rules? If making it themselves means dealing with complicated laws or standards, buying might be easier.
  • What's Our Main Focus? They think about whether making the product fits with their main goals.
  • Is the Supply Chain Reliable? If there's a risk of supply problems, this might influence their choice.

The decision to make or buy depends on a mix of costs, capabilities, and strategic goals. Companies need to carefully weigh these factors to choose the best option.

What advantages does e-procurement software offer in make-or-buy decisions?

E-procurement software automates procurement processes, manages transportation costs, improves supplier relationships, and provides data analytics, real-time supplier performance monitoring, and collaborative tools, all contributing to enhanced decision-making and overall procurement effectiveness.

How does informed decision-making maximize profitability in hardware-centered companies?

By considering various factors, conducting detailed cost analysis, leveraging purchasing software, and aligning decisions with strategic goals, executives can optimize financial resources, control costs, and drive business success.

Remember, each company's situation is unique, so it's essential to adapt the make-or-buy decision-making process to your specific circumstances and goals.

Tori Katz
Content specialist
Tori has a deep expertise in procurement and digital transformation technologies within the hardware industry. Author of extensive guides on strategic procurement practices and technology implementations. Focuses on improving operational efficiency and strategic growth through content.

Table of Contents